Unraveling of the Carry Trade

We’ve been talking about the carry trade unwind for the past couple of days.  The moves in the forex market yesterday and during Asian trading last night ran counter to that assumption.  There was a reversal upwards in the yen crosses, especially CADJPY, AUDJPY and NZDJPY.  The late rebound in the Dow also buoyed USDJPY, as that currency pair has assiduously followed the ups and downs in the equities markets for some time now.  But I am here to tell you that the prognosis with regards to the currencies in the United States and Japan is still yen-positive and dollar-negative.

Let’s starts with the bad news for the US dollar.  The bond market is pricing in a 100% chance of an interest rate cut in January.  DailyFX.com has a fascinating take on the interest rate speculation through a look at the comments of various US monetary policy makers, with the ultimate scenario suggesting a more dovish outlook for the Fed.  The ADP survey shows terrible job growth numbers, coming in at only 75K.  Earnings for most US corporations continue to be relatively stellar, but the money refuses to trickle down, and dollar bulls may have to come to terms with a slowdown in US expansion.

Coming to the yen, most currency analysts see still more room for the room to grow.  The Chicago Board Options Exchanges’ market volatility index (VIX) hit a yearly high yesterday, and greater volatility is a death knell for the carry trade.  Kathy Lien of FXCM posts a two-year chart of USDJPY that will not provide comfort for yen bears.  The interesting thing about the chart is not that it necessarily signals a move downward in the currency pair but that it demonstrates the potential of a possible drop.  And that drop would be disastrous for those still long on the carry trade.

For some months now, dips in the yen crosses have not really been something to worry about; rather, these dips have been seen by Japanese retail investors as opportunities to short the yen.  There has been talk all over the market about “Japanese housewives” beating the pros and serving to stabilize the market by keeping carry trades alive.  But a recent Bloomberg report claims that the risk appetite for Japanese traders is dropping.  They are wary of selling the yen now because they anticipate still more appreciation for the currency, which has the potential to be a self-fulfilling prophecy.  And contributing to the growth of the Japanese yen are the losses all over the hedge fund market in the United States.  The hedge funds were some of the primary drivers of the carry trade, and their exits from the forex market (at least in this limited capacity) might serve notice to the rest of the market that the carry trade is, indeed, unwinding.