Don’t Be Fooled by the Rebound in Yen Crosses

The carry trade is not back. At all. Stay away for right now. The Dow rallied to close 150 points higher yesterday, and yen crosses followed that stock market rally. The high-yielding currencies, especially, made back a lot of their losses. But the upward movement is likely to be temporary because the current market is not conducive to the carry trade.

Volatility is still significant (the stock market may have ended in positive territory, but it wavered back and forth throughout the day). Risk aversion in the market is at a high level. This is the reason that US Treasuries continue to do well; the bonds gained 1.6% last month, second-best performance of all major international government bonds. And then there are the comments yesterday out of China threatening to dump dollars in response to protectionist legislation in the United States. No rational observer of the market actually thinks this is a likely possibility, but the chance is there. If nothing else, the proclamation by the government researcher reminded investors (in the forex market and elsewhere) of the potential power that China holds to disrupt international financial markets. And the fact remains that we do not have a long-term record to rely on of responsible financial administration out of China. The more people are afraid of risk, the worse the carry trade does.

The carry trade is a complicated proposition for anyone participating in the FX market. That’s why so many people get it wrong all the time, including those who make their living trading the currency. There’s so much information bouncing around the market, and traders are relying on fundamentals and technical analysis and have trouble deciding when different signals suggest different actions. As sacrilegious as it might sound, traders might actually be relying on too much information.

The great thing about the internet is it brings real-time news about everything right to our fingertips. But too many choices (for a trader) can actually be a bad thing. There’s a book out right now called The Paradox of Choice, and it’s about how, at a certain point, more options actually reduce the amount of choices available for an individual. We are paralyzed by the sheer number of things that we look at, and so we are unable to focus (or choose) the most valuable information. Bringing it back to the carry trade, the important observation to keep in mind is the following: carry trade thrive on three market conditions: (1) low volatility in international financial markets, (2) cheap money (or credit) and (3) a strong risk appetite among investors. The carry trade will not rebound because none of those three conditions are met in the current market climate.

The FX trading last night is evidence of this point. EUR/JPY, which has acted as a proxy for carry trade popularity, lost 200 points. The Swiss franc gained support through both a run away from the carry trade and a run toward safe havens. The high yielding currencies will continue to lose ground as both phenomena continue. USD/JPY will be the one of the few yen crosses to buck the trend because of the US dollar’s status as a store of value and a safe haven. But that is an abnormality and should not fool traders into thinking the carry trade is back.